Subscribe to feed Latest Entries

Concerted Efforts and Synthesis Workshops

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 10 May 2012
The MRI

One of the main outputs of the MRI Global Commission was a set of mind maps related to themes that themselves emerged at the Perth Conference in September 2010. These mind maps record the thoughts and ideas of Commission members about how the MRI should pursued these themes in the future. One of my main tasks since the Commission meeting has been to translate these thoughts and ideas is more concrete project ideas that the community could pursue and the the MRI Coordination Office could support. While these proposals hardly rank as state secrets, we are not disseminating them widely but have rather asked Commission members for their review first.  If you, the reader, are interested in putting some effort into designing these future "Concerted Efforts" then send us a message via the website.

Soon after London, a select group of scholars from around the world convened at the Park Hotel in Asechi to participate in the IGBP/MRI Synthesis Workshop on Changing Mountain Cryosphere and its Downstream Impacts. This workshop lead to a commitment by Bodo Bookhagen and Ray Bradley to co-edit a synthesis paper with help from Wouter Buytaert, Bryan Mark and Sandy Milner. We expect to see this synthesis paper soon with a Policy Brief for IGBP later in the summer.

As MRI has two more Synthesis Workshops this year (one next week in Colorado and one in September in Switzerland) it is important to critique how we run the workshops. My observations from Aeschi:

1) It always takes longer than you think.  We programmed 15 minutes for talks but participants spent at least that much time again in discussion after the talks. This was time well spent re: the objectives of the meeting but of course put us way off schedule. We recovered somewhat by halting the presentations earlier than foreseen on day 1 (and moving the rest of the presentations to day 2) and using the rest of the day discussing the lessons learned from the talks given on day 1.


2)  Groups cannot produce outlines. Outlines must be proposed by one/two persons and revised by the group.   We started the meeting with only very rough outline. We then spent most of the meeting  discussing what needed to be covered in the outline but in the end it was simply impossible for the group to write an outline.

Two people with two "advisors" worked until midnight on the second day to produce the outline based on all the input given be others. The "two people" also became the two lead authors. 

I don't assert that we wasted effort over the first two days of the meeting, but I would assert that it would have been much easier if we had had a more complete outline at the outset of the meeting and had then related each presentation to the outline: did presentation X cause us to change the outline and how?

The alternative argument is that one would not get ownership of the outline and the subsequent writing work if the participants did not feel that they were the originators of the outline.  This is likely true, in which case, see 1) above in spades!

3) A strict outline approach based on assertions is essential to laying the foundation for writing.

The three days we had in Aeschi were not sufficient to get to the writing (see 1 again). Nonetheless the writing will not be very hard because we will have a well-annotated outline, in which each line is an assertion that will be "proved" by points beneath it. The outline does not consist of "topics" because a topic is not a message, and an article is fundamentally about communicating a set of messages.  It is surprisingly difficult to get people to "say what they mean". They tend to want to say "what they are speaking about" so one must get them passed that to get at  the real messages.   So for instance when people have said "hydrographs under climate change" we have had to push them to get assertions "hydrographs in the future will show more pronounced seasonality" and so on.

Once people know what points they are supposed to be supporting or proving, writing is easy.

4) Ownership must move from the organizers to the participants. Toward the end of the meeting I have made myself scarce as, despite my strong feelings about what should be in the document, I will not be writing it, and so shouldn't have power over the content. The content has to be that of the participants.

I am sure that I will have yet more observations as a result of the Building Resilience Synthesis Workshop next week.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Are you a Key Contact? Here you get the answer.

by Astrid
Astrid
Environmental Scientist, Development Specialist, Writer and Illustrator.
User is currently offline
on Monday, 07 May 2012
MRI Europe

Are you a key contact person in mountain research?

0 votes

The Mountain Session at PuP and the subsequent MRI Global Commission

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 26 April 2012
The MRI

This is what my wife calls "repurposing": I wrote this for the IHDP newsletter so I might as well post it here first.

Mountains as Arenas for Adaptation to Global Change

 

The global change in mountains research community, which in the past has often emphasized biogeophysical aspects of global change, focused squarely on institutional arrangements in its session at the PuP Conference, Mountains as arenas for adaptation to global change. The session organizers included UNESCO, the Mountain Research Initiative (MRI), the University of Highlands and Islands (UK), the University of Bern (CH) and Makerere University (UG). The session. The presenters and their abstracts can be found on the PuP Conference site. The MRI has made available recordings of the slides and the speakers' talks through its website .

 

Martin Price started the session by highlighting the utility of Biosphere Reserves as sites for experimentation on adaptation to global change, as the concept of Biosphere Reserves includes at its core both human use of the environment and research. Bob Nakileza and Willem Ferguson described transboundary conservation areas in the mountain regions of Africa similarly as sites for research on adaptation. Stephan Rist and Bishnu Ray Upreti looked outside government reserve boundaries at common property regimes and reported on pre-requisites for the expansion of such regimes. Jörg Balsiger with a host of co-authors reviewed a wide range of regional governance arrangements in mountains from NGO alliances to treaty organizations as potential adaptive mechanisms. Finally Christian Huggel and his co-authors examined the mechanisms by which scientific expertise can inform adaptation in mountain regions.

 

The session showed a wide range of institutional arrangements, of which many if not most could be seen as potentially adaptive. The very diversity of arrangements is itself an interesting research topic, but in any event, the inventory is very far from complete and needs to be pursued further.

 

The research community needs as well to address the performance and effectiveness of these institutional arrangements as adaptive mechanisms. These institutional arrangements all have idiosyncratic origins and are thus not simply different responses to the same demand, in the case for adaptation to global change, but in fact are responses to a great variety of different expectations. Thus we must disentangle their performance relative to their avowed missions from that related to adaptation to global change.

 

Finally and in keeping with the transdisciplinary thrust of the PuP Conference, research certainly has a role to play in the conscious development of new institutional arrangements focused on adaptation to global change, as opposed to the more academic project of assessing the utility of existing arrangements in a new context. But such research must take seriously engagement with existing network of authority to surmount its own preconceptions and to achieve true co-production of knowledge.

______________

Mountain Research Initiative Global Commission

 

Thirty-three researchers from five continents, and from political science to climatology met together as the Mountain Research Initiative Global Commission at Imperial College on 30 March 2012, the day after the PuP Conference, to incorporate lessons learned from the Conference and to chart new directions for the Initiative.

 

Prominent among the lessons learned at the Conference was the on-going consolidation within global change research community into a single project, Future Earth. This consolidation has many origins and implications, but on the face of it, MRI is well aligned with the motivations behind this new project. MRI's objectives have always included one on the provision of useful knowledge to policy and practice, something that is now central to Future Earth. Beyond that, MRI's emphasis on interdisciplinary research within the context of a kind of landscape fits very well the announced objective of more "integrated" research. While other GC research programs have pronounced disciplinary roots, MRI has from the beginning espoused a whole system approach. While espousing and conducting are two different things, but at least our community has a place-based focus that provides a unifying context for our disciplinary pursuits. Finally, MRI has promoted "real projects in real places" for years, principally through the development of regional networks to complement the Global Commission. Thus we are several steps closer than many other projects to incorporating stakeholders and "co-producing" of knowledge. But we are not yet there.

 

As for new directions, the Commission discussed ten different themes that emerged from our community's last major conference, Global Change and the World's Mountains, held in Perth in September 2010:

· Mountains in the Global South

· Nature and Trajectory of Ecological Systems under Global Change

· Nature of Institutions and Social Systems and their Interactions with Ecological Systems

· Nature of Global Social Drivers

· Long-Term Mountain Observing Systems

· Ecosystem Services

· Human Agency in the Mountains

· Communication

· Human Presence in the Mountains

· Integrated Analysis and Modeling for Land Sustainability

 

The brainstorming at the meeting was extremely productive and will lead to specific propositions for "Concerted Effort" by the global change in mountains community in the next five years.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

More about PuP

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 05 April 2012
The MRI

Before I launch into more ruminations about Planet Under Pressure, I want to highlight some data. First. I tweeted extensively during the Conference. You can find those tweets under my Twitter name, MRIDIR, or under the hashtag #planetconf. I have been reviewing the conference today, a week later, and the tweets are a great record for me. I recommend that you try tweeting at your next conference, if only as a good way of recalling what happened.

And I suggest that you review some of the recording plenary talks. These are available here.

For the life of me, I can't understand why the organizers didn't record the speakers' slides along with their speeches! I's clear to me that MRI knows how to do this better than Elsevier!

On day 1 you should check out the talks by Diane Liverman and Will Steffens, talks that I mention in my earlier post. On day 2 Yves de Boer' is quite good, and during the panel discussion the business member, Keith Clarke, seemed particularly lucid. In general the business people at the conference seemed much less confused about social process and the ways forward than did the scientists.

I strongly recommend that you watch the plenaries on day 3, particularly the first by Richard Wilkinson, and the third by Laurence Tubiana, as well as the panel discussion led by Andy Revkin, formerly of the NYTimes. These may have been the best talks of the conference.

Finally on day 4, Johan Rockstrum's description of the new Future Earth consortium is very good. Richard Norgaard also spoke on day 4 and his video is under Parallel Sessions.

So what did I get out of all this? I was struck by the endless repetition of "need for new governance" with very little analysis of how to get there or even why we need to get there, other than the obvious observation that we don't seem to be approaching sustainable development very quickly, and in particularly have largely failed to address anthropogenic climate change. Laurence Tubiana said it well in her talk: in the 40 years since Stockholm 1972 (which is pretty much my entire professional life, and so I take this personally), sustainable development has been useful only as a diagnostic measure and has failed utterly to provide pathways toward its achievement.

To me the central question is "why?" Whenever I say this, there is a cacophony of responses. My soixante-huitard cousin harangues corporations. Andy Revkin talks about the scale of the problem exceeding our culture's grasp. Others talk about the need to change consciousness and so on. All of these may be true to some extent, but the fact is that the global change social science community has not examined this question as the social science question that it really is.

I do not delude myself into thinking that this is a trivial project nor that the data needed are easily available, but we must first see the question itself as something worthy of study, not just speculation and anecdote. As a result of this failure the community flails about, lurching from one mantra ("learning societies", "communication", "transdisciplinarity") to another without the benefit of evidence. (This is not entirely true as IGEC did a decent job and when Oran Young speaks it is still worth listening. Nonetheless I don't think that they went far enough into the dynamics of change.)

For me the problem takes almost crystalline form when we speak of "internalizing externalities". Numerous people correctly diagnosed our predicament as a market failure: that the full costs of our activities, particularly our consumption of fossil carbon energy, are not included in the costs of the goods and services that we buy. I suspect that few would contest that if these externalities were internalized, the market would work efficiently to reduce if not eliminate them. I think Richard Norgaard clearly said as much, that markets work well within the context of the incentives that underlie them. Such an approach is completely congruent with the prevailing market ideology of the world, and simply requires "getting the price right". And there are many "revenue neutral" options by which higher prices for fossil carbon (and other environmental damages) are offset by lower income taxes, so that one creates a price signal without necessarily changing the overall economic situation of households and firms. Yet for all the options that exist we have systematically failed to do so.

The response of many in the conference is then to promote changes in consciousness: less consumption, gross national happiness instead of product, etc. I see much merit in these idea, yet I fail to understand how they are easier to achieve - a quasi-religious conversion for billions of people - than simply getting the price of coal and oil to include their full costs in the world's commodity markets. I suspect those advocates might answer is that we would need this change in consciousness in order to change the political economy that sets world energy prices. While I don't know if I agree with that statement either, it at least embodies a hypothesis about the force and structures that lead to social change (or the maintenance of the status quo). We should treat such an implication as a hypothesis to examine, one of many that that global change social science should explore!

Andy Revkin said at one point that he doubted that the international climate negotiations would have succeeded even if there hadn't been a deliberate campaign by special interests to discredit the science. This is an experiment I dearly wished we could run: what would the world be like if there hadn't been such a campaign? Would we in fact have been able to stay with a 2°C warming instead of a 3-4°C warming? Some points in history are critical, where taking one route closes off forever other options. It is painful of course to recognize that we could have had a much better world if the "merchants of doubt" had not weighed so heavily on our political system. I fear that in the past 20 years we have indeed missed the turnoff to a better world, and that while we shouldn't give up, the world that we could've achieved is no longer available to us. Discounting the role of disinformation makes that miss marginally more palatable: maybe we couldn't have made that turn anyway, not because of a conspiracy but because the larger culture was in the way. However I doubt that assessment, and would like to focus the light of critical inquiry on the question.

There is of course much more to understand than just the role of well-financed interest groups. While they are undoubtedly important, and maybe more important than we generally believe, they are nonetheless part of a much larger process of social change, or more grandiloquently, human development. It is this system, the human equivalent of a coupled ocean-land surface- atmosphere model, that we lack. Yet without a clearer delineation of the structure and function of this system, all proposals for how science should interact with society are fundamentally anecdotal. While they are possibly true and might be "win-win", would any of us accept such anecdotes about oceans or atmosphere or the land surface without proof?

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Planet under Pressure

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 27 March 2012
The MRI

Upon first entering the huge ExCel Center (more like the Shanghai combination airport and train station!) I not surprisingly bumped into a bunch on familiar people: Dave Schimel, Dennis Ojima, Ray Bradley, Prakash Tiwari and his wife Bhagwati, Chad Dear, Jeremy Littell, Jörg Balsiger, who else am I forgetting. It is gratifying to see that some of the mountain community is here.

Technically the conference is close but not equal to the AGU. The hall has wireless everywhere but very few power outlets, so you can tweet for awhile but soon power management becomes an issue. The organizers are streaming the plenary talks, and have established two-way communication with remote sites, so that observers at distant locations can send in questions via SMS or Twitter. The website allows some searching but if you want to find out who is speaking about mountains, you can only search the pdf of poster title, not session presentations. The AGU supports searches much better!

The talks: the first two by Diane Liverman and Will Steffens, focusing respectively on drivers of change and responses by the earth system were excellent and I hope that we can eventually provide a link on our website to either their ppts or to video stream put out by the conference. The main points here were that the drivers, principally population growth, GHG intensity and land use are still increasing but their rate of change is dropping. Most interesting statistic from Liverman: since 1950, average child/woman global has dropped from around 5 to around 2.5. This highlights the central role that women play in global change via their fertility. (Of course, as a husband and a father of three women I know that women also run the rest of the world too!). To be clear, LIverman did not say that GHG emissions were bending lower as we all know that they are not, but rather that GHG intensity has declined significantly, so we can say that the situation could have been worse than it is. Finally she should a great slide about GHG emission by income level within one country (UK? US?) that clearly showed that the impact of the higher income deciles was 50- 100% greater than the poorer deciles.

All that said, Will Steffens pointed out that the physical indicators of the earth system (e.g. atmospheric CO2) do not show any such slowing of the rate of change. He emphasized complex systems and tipping points, discussing the ice sheets, the Amazon and Siberia permafrost as three important possible tipping points. The map he showed (which we have all seen before) shows Tibet as another potential tipping point, the only one that explicitly involves a mountain region. This could conceivably be an MRI Concerted Effort.

Sandra Diaz gave an overview of how the tree of life (an evolutionary view) and the web of life (the trophic view) are being pruned by humans. Not only are we losing branches of the tree but we are also lopping away the top-level consumers while jacking up the primary producers with nitrogen.

Anthony Giddens, a sociologist, addressed the state of humanity. Here again my unease with the community's inability to articulate a clear social science vision was exacerbated. Giddens focused largely on the unreality of international treaty negotiations and stressed much more action at multiple levels of governance. He discussed the need for a new politics of "utopian realism", a theme that is well put, but once again he failed to address how one creates such a politics, and did not sketch how a more serious social science research agenda could lay the basis for such an approach. Nor did he offer any insights about economics and markets, something the Watson notes - "must get the economics right" - but similarly failed to articulate as a program. ON the light rail last night coming back for an incredible Indian dinner in London, Jörg Balsiger said that all this has been done already by others not present. We as a research community need to find that work and elevate it.

I had a similar problem with the panel discussion of eminent folks, not one of whom said, in reply to "What is one thing that you would think would lead to progress?", increase the market cost of fossil carbon. And it was not as if what they did say was easier or more likely to occur ("more transdisciplinary science", etc., etc.). I figure that if you are free to suggest things that plausible but nonetheless difficult, raising the price of fossil C would be at the top of the list!  The social science question is thus "since such a change would be both biophysically effective and would fit with the current ideology of market economics, why hasn't it happened?"

 

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Alpine fire outbreak on the Rwenzori Mountains (Mountains of the Moon – Uganda)

by Saliou Niassy
Saliou Niassy
MSc Natural Science and Biology Ph.D Zoology (Entomology)
User is currently offline
on Monday, 26 March 2012
MRI Africa

By Dr. Hilde Eggermont. Alpine fire outbreak on the Rwenzori Mountains (Mountains of the Moon – Uganda).

 

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Mountain Research: Are we heading to the right direction

by Astrid
Astrid
Environmental Scientist, Development Specialist, Writer and Illustrator.
User is currently offline
on Friday, 16 March 2012
MRI Europe

Communication technologies and innovations of the last few decades enabled science to draw from a large body of expertise and to aggregate data and information. The mountain research community, including the 7000 members of the Mountain research Initiative, is only one of these science sectors. Did this new era of networked science make an impact on the amount and quality of global change research conducted in mountains? If yes, did this research contribute to the sustainable development in these regions? These questions are obviously related to the drivers and underlying processes that steer research at different levels.

Who sets the Research Agenda?

Researchers are small cogs in a big wheel primarily powered by the strategic decisions of international and national funding institutions, which are again embedded in political frameworks subjected to other manifold forces. Some institutions, such as the European Framework Programme, strongly stipulate the kind of research conducted. Hence, scientists are challenged to fit their interests into the given frameworks.

Yet, science communities have their own priorities and voices. The GLOCHAMORE project provides an excellent example of how the global mountain research community agreed on a joint research agenda for global change research in mountain regions. The GLOCHAMORE strategy provides a common basis and the achievements of the UNESCO MAB Programme in implementing the proposed research in mountain biosphere reserves around the world is a proof that research can indeed be stimulated by internal forces (see GLOCHAMOST).

The Mountain Research Community Decides on the Way Forward

Five years after the end of the GLOCHAMORE project, the Conference on Global Change and the World’s Mountains held in Perth, Scotland, in 2010 offered the opportunity to analyze the state and progress of mountain research and its contribution to sustainable development, as well as to reflect on required reorientations of research agendas. A 3-step assessment of the research presented by 450 researchers from around the world yielded a synthesis paper, the Perth Synthesis, identifying research needs and emerging themes for sustainable development in mountain regions, while relating the reflections to the analytical structure of the Global Land Project and the Grand Challenges for Global Sustainability put forth by the International Council for Science.

Where does the Perth Conference participants see the gaps? (Photo C. Drexler 2010).

The Perth Synthesis in a Nutshell

The analysis revealed that despite the growing recognition of the importance of integrative research, the mountain research community still focuses on environmental drivers of change and on interactions within ecological systems. Only a small percentage of current research seeks to enhance understanding of social systems and of interactions between social and ecological systems. A greater effort is needed to disentangle and assess different drivers of change and to investigate impacts on Ecosystem Services. Sociocultural drivers affecting collective behavior as well as incentive systems devised by policy and decision makers require more in-depth investigation. As a consequence, this presupposes effective collaboration between ecological and social sciences and a coordinated effort of the mountain research community to convey the Perth messages to representatives of national and European funding agencies.

Scientists are indeed cogs in a wheel: they are driven and driving!

 

0 votes

Kudos to AfroMont, Kudos to MRI

by Saliou Niassy
Saliou Niassy
MSc Natural Science and Biology Ph.D Zoology (Entomology)
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 15 February 2012
MRI Africa
Multi-Stakeholder Meeting for UNCSD Rio+20 Conference The conference venue was at South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI). Our role in that meeting was to make sure that African stakeholders are aware of the existence of the Network (AfroMont) and its activities. We also contributed in improving the Zero draft which will be submitted next week. I was very excited when I read a paragraph depicting the importance of mountains on the Rio+20 Zero Draft for Africa. Thus, the idea of meeting policy-makers and enlightening them on crucial environmental issues can help in sensitizing communities about research outputs. Elise Haber, one of the South African stakeholders for Rio+20, told me "I used the Lucerne conference in Switzerland and the conference in Uganda (Mbale) outputs as a basis" to elaborate on a Mountains section. The paragraph is under Chapter V Framework for action and follow-up, Section Priority/ key/ thematic/cross-sectorial issues and areas, article 94.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting 2011: Part 2

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 14 February 2012
The MRI

What themes emerged at the AGU 2011 meeting that the MRI community might want to follow up with a Synthesis Workshop, or with a new category of activity that I'll just call a Concerted Effort?

Treeline appeared in many talks and posters, perhaps not surprisingly as Session B12B focused on treelines! I particularly liked W.K. Smith's talk in which he addressed how high elevation treeline environments differed from arctic or antarctic treeline environments, with for instance much higher radiation loads and much lower partial pressures. I noted shortly after the AGU that a recent paper by Malanson et al. in JAAAR proposed next steps in treeline research, so perhaps we don't need a Synthesis Workshop  but rather a Concerted Effort to pursue the lines of inquiry laid out by George, Lynn and Co.  A treeline effort modeled on MIREN(the mountains invasive network with standard protocols, etc.)  might be a viable option.

Many people reported on the use of smart sensor networks. When I asked if there were any platform that supported dialogue among developers and users of such sensor networks, no one seemed to know of any. So we have a very promising approach being developed by many different labs around the world with little interaction. Hmmm, this sounds to me like a good topic for a platform hosted by MRI.

Himalayan glaciers were also the topic of many different projects but it appeared to me that the projects weren't conferring with each other. There were projects funded by USAID, by NASA, by the EU and so on. And there will certainly be a number of papers that appear in the near future that attempt to fill the gap created by the IPCC AR4 gaffe. Still I wonder if a workshop where all the researchers could confront the data and analyses of others would not be a useful adjunct to the appearance of several disconnected summary papers in different journals. The point would not be to eliminate competition or even to seek consensus, but rather to accelerate the process of review and critique.

High resolution analyses and models of mountain meteorology also fascinated me. The role of aerosols in the form of snow, how clouds formed over mountainous islands, the development of jets that impede circulation: it seems that we are still learning quite a lot about the basic mechanisms of mountain meteorology. As climate change occurs physically through changes in these processes, a better understanding of them,  and especially of how changes in forcing will alter them seems like the most effective way to improve our forecasts of climate change.

The MRI Coordination Office has launched a call for new ideas for Synthesis Workshops, some of which might actually be the basis for what I am calling Concerted Efforts. If you want to propose something, click here!

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

El Agua en los Andes

by Pablo
Pablo
Dr. Pablo Lagos MRI Coordinator for the American Cordillera Transect Institu
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 09 February 2012
TCA

El Agua en los Andes.

Los Andes es un lugar increíble, y el que más nos debería importar. Proporciona alimentos, biodiversidad, minerales, turismo y mucho más, pero el agua dulce, que es vital para la vida, en exceso o en escasez puede afectar  seriamente el sustento  de la población.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

S4C Planning Meeting in Smolenice, Slovakia (2-3 February 2012)

by Astrid
Astrid
Environmental Scientist, Development Specialist, Writer and Illustrator.
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 07 February 2012
MRI Europe
From Data to Knowledge, from Knowledge to Action
The icy wind from Siberia ensured that the members of the organizing committee for the Forum Carpaticum 2012 stayed close together when they discussed the planning and implementation of the S4C key event scheduled for early summer. Upon invitation of Lubos Halada, Institute of Landscape Ecology, Slovak Academy of Sciences, more than twenty scientists of the Scientific Organizing Committee gathered for two days at Smolenice Castle to sort and discuss submitted abstracts, and to shape and organize the conference.
Of equal importance was the discussion among the S4C Scientific Steering Commitee members about the far less tangible objectives of the Science for the Carpathians initiative, such as stimulating the dialogue with policy, shaping a Carpathian research area or facilitating the access to data and information for the sake of sustainable development. So far, these topics did not get the attention they actually deserve, despite that fact that such linkage between research and real-life problems has been prominently declared in the title of the next Forum Carpaticum: From Data to Knowledge, from Knowledge to Action.



Trespassing disciplinary borders is like a Siberian wind
Indeed, it takes an extra effort to think beyond thematic and disciplinary conference sessions. Disciplinary sessions allowing interaction among peers with a similar mindset are truely cosy places when Siberian winds bang at the shutters of the Smolenice castle. However, to progress in science, we have to fight against two strong human forces: First, our own desire to organize the scientific world in disciplinary categories, and second, the seduction to talk about things we already know. As described in Michael Nielson's book Reinventing Discovery, people in a group tend to reinforce preconceived ideas rather than to systematically complement their knowledge. We need to invent new tools allowing us to pool all the information we gather, for instance, at a conference like the Forum Carpaticum. Such attempt should go far beyond the publication of extended abstracts. Making use of the "collective knowledge" of the Science for the Carpathians initiative remains a key challenge.

Getting equipped for the future
The discussion around the science-practice-policy gap and the manifold obstacles in the field of data sharing, let alone open science, leaves many of us with discomfort, simply because we are no experts in such fuzzy fields. Moreover, it is questionable if such engagement will yield the academic merit scientists are aiming at.
Yet, in the Research Agenda for the Carpathians, the S4C community clearly declares the intent to take responsibility for advocacy at the policy level and to make an effort to enhance data integration, harmonization and access at the pan-Carpathian scale. Further, with the draft of the Memorandum of Understanding between the S4C and the Interim Secretariate of the Carpathian Convention (ISCC-UNEP), to be signed at the Forum Carpaticum 2012, the Carpathian science community testifies the will to put research into service of Carpathian policy. A clear signal of good will that needs to be followed up by concrete actions - from both, science and policy!
0 votes

International Conference of East African Mountains

by Saliou Niassy
Saliou Niassy
MSc Natural Science and Biology Ph.D Zoology (Entomology)
User is currently offline
on Friday, 27 January 2012
MRI Africa

"There is still hope in Mountain Research in Africa!"

After a brief stay in Kenya, where I attended African Association of Insect Scientists, I met Philip Omondi and Boniface Kiteme. I used the opportunity to introduce the GCRNAM to the african insect scientists community who are still worried about the issue of climate change and how to adapt insect science to the situation. There were two planary lectures on climate change in relation to insect, especially the issue of coffee/tea production in African highlands and the proliferation of the coffee berry borer in a scenario of temperature increase which is likely to favour the pest.

I also had the chance to attend the Mbale meeting. My colleague and friend from icipe Dr. Tino Johanson coordinator the Chiesa project at icipe and I shared the road with Akamba bus from Nairobi to Mbale, just beneath the Ugandan side of Mount-Elgon. At that time, I used to believe that Mountain research in Africa was an uncommon field and I was still trying to convince myself if it was promising field to undertake. Even the program that was given on the website could not give me a hind of the type of research programs that are being conducted in African Mountains by african researchers.

Due to the fragility of mountain ecosystems, it was important for both researchers and policy-makers to identify shortcoming that underpin sustainability, adaptation and resilience regarding to mountain resources. The Mbale conference is the first of its kind in East Africa and was organized by key stakeholders including governmental and non-governmental organizations such as NGOs, Universities etc… The conference was organized by most of the pioneers’ researchers who attended the creation of the Global Change Research Network in African Mountains in 2007 in Kampala. Before the conference I have had several email conversations with Bob Nakileza about the main topics and themes of the conference. Of course we used the opportunity to prepare a key note adress about the Network and the Mountain Research Initiative, our objectives and expected results. The overall conference's objectives were to deliberate upon issues affecting sustainability in East Africa by bringing together researchers working on Mountains in East Africa. By creating such meetings, it will promote South-South collaborations and strengthen international partnership in mountain/highland-lowland research. The conference aimed at publishing eventually quality publications in form of an edited volume in mountain research.

Over 40 communications from 60 attendees were presented in the ICEAM conference at Mbale Resort Hotel. Various topics including ecosystem services, adaptation, climate change, conservation and biodiversity, urban-rural interactions, cultural heritage, trans-boundary conflicts have been discussed. At that moment I confidently stated "There is still hope in Mountain Research in Africa!"

Ecosystem services and Livelihoods

Mountains regions are subjected to environmental stress due to populations increase and poor governance in addition to the issue of climate change. There are many reasons that may cause conflicts: insecurity from illegal arms, land mines (UXO), cattle raiding across regional borders, cultural disharmony and environmental shocks (ASALs). However, most of these conflicts have severe repercussions on the environments. Mr. Francis Onditi came up with a talk about “Shared borders, common problems: policy options for a comprehensive livelihood adaptation framework in Eastern Africa” which depicted the real situation on trans-boundary calamities due to population movement affecting mountain resources and ecosystems services. In his paper, Francis described a participatory rural appraisal (PRA) to follow up and predict potential conflicts in East African Mountains which can be used by the East Africa Community.

In South Sudan for instance, the drivers of livelihood-based conflict are mainly the seasonal changes; for example, in Torit County, cattle raids tend to occur on a weekly basis. The estimates of human deaths related to cattle were 15-20 per months (EES Strategic Plan 2008/10). It is believed that conflicts are more common in the months of Dec and Jan rain fall distribution).

In Kenya and Ethiopia border, the drivers of livelihood-based conflict in Ilemi Triangle include: colonial administration (British & Italians); cultural differences between communities (Turkana, Didinga, Toposa, Inyangatom and Dissanech), territorial disputes. The perception of residents on the influence of territorial boundaries was not sharp and this is due to many factors for instance; free movement accelerated by the need to accommodate increasing pastoral productivity, population increase and of course ecological stresses.

The “Gun Culture”; in most communities in East Africa, guns are viewed as central fixture in the determination of social and cultural hierarchies. For that reason, there are homemade arms by local Blacksmith. There is strong pressure on communities to acquire guns for self-defense as well as prestige for instance in Kenya-Tanzania border.

In South Sudan and Ugandan border, civilians are often rapped by the official government forces like the Owinj Ki Bull and Narus black spots. The regions are characterized by elusive boundaries and there is a constant movement of livelihood assets across borders. Such conditions are favorable for criminal activities of rebel groups and militia- Notably the Didinga and Buya along the SS-EAC roads.

The study showed that livelihood failure across the borders is largely determined by inter-communal factors such as culture and beliefs. Interventional programs must focus on household coping strategies and gender roles. The emerging new generational gap is critical and should be considered as part of livelihood intervention framework. Militarized development among some countries is a spoiling factor as witnessed along water points. The focus should be on the emerging livelihood-based conflict triggers as opposed to the traditional conflict drivers. However, there is still a lot of effort on how to obtain information timely and share it with relevant actors to support decisive strategic interventions.

Still in the theme of ecosystem services, I listened to Dr. Festus Bagoora presentation on “Soil loss variations with Inter-annual rainfall, Slope and Seasonal cropping systems in the highland region of south-western Uganda”. Soil erosion and mass-wasting are major environmental problem in the humid mountainous and highland regions of Southern Uganda. Heavy rains and soil degradation in conjunction to climate change and human activity could be the mains reasons. Dr. Bagoora indicated that: there is a prevailing need to adopt both physical and agronomic soil conservation systems to protect the ecosystems for resilience.

Ecosystems play a great role in our daily lives but, we tend to underscore their importance, thinking that environmental benefits are “FREE”. Although water is not considered as part of the ecosystem services, the processes of purification for its availability are strongly linked to community development. In that regard, Babu and Ogaram presented their work on “Ecosystem Services for Urban Water Supply: Case Study, Manafwa River System- Mbale, Uganda”. Ecosystem degradation and particularly deforestation are major threats to the provision of ecosystem services (water purification, soil erosion control). Inadequate resource monitoring and protection may soon lead to supply shortages in major urban centers. Babu and Ogaram tried to determine the trends in water quality of the Manafwa River and to evaluate the spatial differences in the water quality along the Manafwa River. Water quality, treatability and the cost in the next decade were assessed as well. In a timeframe of 10 years, they reported an increasing trend of water turbidity due to solide fractions emanating from mountain soil erosion. Between 1999 and 2007, water alkalinity was decreasing at 1mg/L CaCO3/yr. Though the FC counts generally decreased, it was not statistically significant (17 CFU/yr). There were significant differences in chemical usage between the DRY (lower) and WET season (higher). The unit treatment cost in 2007 was 61 UGX/m3and in 2015; it will be 80 UGX/m3. This degradation in water quality and purification which is an ecosystem service can be attributed to land use differences. The wet season alum dosage is higher than the dry is due to high erosion- a consequence of widespread destruction of natural vegetative cover in the catchment. The authors stated that “If Manafwa water works was situated at Mount Elgon National Park (un-degraded area upstream); there would probably be no need of extensive treatment of the raw water”. 

In conclusion for that interesting presentation, “the costs of ecosystem services are normally underscored not until the effects of their degradation become visible (e.g. increasing water treatment costs and water tariffs)”.

“Farmers’ Perceptions of the Erosion Risk on Mt. Elgon: Implications to Soil and Water Conservation”. Dr Yazid Bamutaze explained how farmer’s perceptions influence implementation of SWC measures on Mt. Elgon in Uganda. He looked at the awareness of erosion as an environmental hazard positively influences field implementation of SWC measures and how farmers of education influence implementation of SWC. The study showed that farmers are aware of the occurrence of erosion and its negative consequences. They also farmers perceive the quality of land to be decreasing. As predicted by models, farmer’s perception matched with scientific predictions. However, there is a gap between perceptions and SWC actions probably due to Institutional constraints which need further investigations (labor, incomes, gender), historical approaches etc. Dr. Yazid recommended that there is need to harness the high level of awareness of erosion as a hazard and to explore promising strategies to incentivise farmers to conserve.

In East Africa, Mountains forests are threatened by farmers who are looking for more fertile land. Clare Mutumba et al. assessed the “The impact of land use and cover on soil organic carbon stocks”. She conducted survey in Mt Elgon to look at “the impact of land use and cover on soil organic carbon stocks”. She compared soils of several altitudes of the Atari catchment considering slopes and depth. The major outcome of her study was “The higher the vegetation cover and diversity in a land use and cover the more the soil organic stock”. In response to land degradation and soil erosion which are the results of poor farming methods, deforestation, due to population increase. David Kiirya presented “Crop residue utilization for soil productivity improvement, livestock feeding and erosion control in Mt. Elgon”. Since “Poverty and environmental problems are both children of the same mother, and that mother is ignorance”, the consequence of these bad practices is high cost of inputs by farmers. Mr. Kiirya and his team suggested the integration of organic manures that could sustain soil fertility in Mountain land where soil erosion is a rule. The technique is beneficial in soil fertility improvement, yield increment and runoff control. Although results are not immediately seen due to terrain-floods, the nature of soil texture is very important. Crop residues are a useful resource in soil fertility improvement. They increase crop yields and many farmers from the study sites are currently using crop residues effectively. The approach is generally cost effective and sustainable towards meeting soil conservation requirements. There is a need to improving the knowledge gap of farmers in making on-spot decision aid tools.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Report South Africa

by Saliou Niassy
Saliou Niassy
MSc Natural Science and Biology Ph.D Zoology (Entomology)
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 26 January 2012
MRI Africa

Personal perception of the importance of Global Change Research Network in African Mountains

The introduction to the Global Change Research Network in African Mountain (Afromount) has been well perceived by all the researchers and scientists that we met in South Africa. Many of them were already aware of the existence of such a Network since launched in Kampala Uganda in 2007 and the Mountain Research Initiative (MRI); however, there have been very few echoes or news about our activities. Actually, very few scientists were aware of its functionality and its objectives.

Current research projects regarding to Global Change Research in African mountains

In Kwazulu Natal

DSC02704

I started my trip to Pietmarritzburg to meet Sue Van Rensburg who introduced me to staff of the South African Environmental Observatory Network and other agents of the KwazuluNatal Wildlife. Currently, there are many on-going projects and research studies. The South African Environmental Observatory Network SAEON created since 2008 carries out diverse activities ranging from Hydrology, Ecology, and Geology to biodiversity and agro-forestry. Major focuses are on the Drakensberg area on the grasslands, forest and costal area and the Fynbosch in the Cape. While SAEON is trying to set more updated techniques and laboratories, there is focuson the Drakensberg and the Folded Mountains in the Capes in collaboration with many other universities and institutions. Dr. Jemma Finsch has been working a lot on Paleo-ecological studies in the wetlands; She also carried a lot of research in Easter Arc of Africa. Her work consisted mainly in characterizing both Eco environment and the hydrological status of the Drakensberg using probes. Paleo-environmental studies are one of the key activities that unify Forest, wetlands and grassland research and take into account climate change aspects. The relations between the different segments of the vegetation are being also established. Paleo-environment work in relation to the Drakensberg wetlands is also being investigated.

The Maloti-Drakensberg Trans frontier Project (MDTP), which includes five provinces of South Africa and one country Lesotho is also a key project that is being conducted in Mountain area. Major focuses are on biodiversity (tree, birds, frogs, reptiles and mammals and plants).

Interesting research studies have been carried out by Hylton Adie and Ian Rushworth. Forest plant distribution, abundance in the Drakensberg area has been studied. The distribution of Podocarpus a forest plant is being studies in the Drakensberg form the berg, grassland up to the cost to identify the eventual changes in the distribution pattern of the species and the reason that may explain the shifts. The dynamic of remarkable plant species in relation to shade, grassland and altitude importance is one of the major topics that are being evaluated. The role of plant nodules (symbiotic microorganisms) to understand the changes or shifts between forests and grasslands is also considered as well. Water availability in relation to the wetlands, forest and grassland occupies a major part of research in SAEON. Especially the expansion of Pine trees which can affect the water flow up to 10%. Pine tree plantation also affect to some extent the soil fertility and architecture by allowing erosion. Since they are invasive species, Pine tree and Eucalyptus can also invade natural environment and outcompete native species. The issue of land use and management is also at the centre of SAEON and KZN Wildlife concern.

Cape Town

DSC02748

In the Cape, SAEON also focus on biodiversity studies, monitoring of lands, and livestock. The water catchment project started since 1937 and the current activity is to try “reviving” the system that has stopped for over 10 years. Dr. Nicky Allsop is one of the Fynbos, which is a particular type of Mountain vegetation. According to her, a complex of Aracea (750), Proteacea (200) are found in the Cape. Potential collaborations with researchers in Mount Mulanje (Malawi) will improve knowledge in the diversity of the Fynbos. The same issue of Pine trees and soil vulnerability, which was described in the Drakensberg  is being addressed and Biocontrol system or early detection programs are being planned to contain invasive plant species.

South Africa is considered as an arid country; the issue of water availability in relation to community development and other water management systems such as cloud and fog precipitations are being studied as well in the Cape. In that regard projects and concepts have been submitted to the department of water affairs to promote techniques such as foggy precipitation for communities living in Mountain areas and the possibility to increase the number of water catchements in South Africa.

DSC02688

In term of Wild life conservation, KZN Wild life focus on the effect of climate change on the vegetation as well as the bio geographical corridors in the Drakensberg area. Activities such Conservation Planning process of vulnerable species or endangered species aiming at influencing policy-maker and managers are being conducted. Survey data in different biomes are being used to draw maps and characterize the distribution of animal and plants in South Africa using GIS techniques. In terms of collaboration, countries like Angola, Egypt, Lybia and Mozambique have benefitted a lot from the KZN expertise.

Climatologists are also very involved in Mountain research; in collaboration with the Water Research Commission Infrastructures, Agriculture Research Environment data are available and allow generating models. Models have been designed based of collected data (Evaporation, Hydrology) that maybe help in predicting the effects of climate change in water availability, food security. Although the issue of accessibility in the Mountains and Theft have been reported, data since 1970 are currently used as a work basis. Capacity building programs do exist with the Sudanese, Eritrea, Botswana and Swaziland governments. 

DSC02681DSC02721

Major research outputs, achievements and relevant references (publications, reports)

In South Africa, meteorological data were stored since 1930’s.Therefore, many projects in relation to water, land and biodiversity management have been conducted. Rainfall stations and catchments that have been placed at different regions of South Africa since 1937 are still active, although there was a break of 6 years. Dr Mark Savage a climatologist at the University of Kwazulu Natal attested that climatic data have been used to design models for important crops such as Maize. We had the Chance to meet Prof. Bruce Ewitson at the University of Cape Town, he is actually working on data storage a collection in collaboration with other African Researchers. Although his focus is not mainly in Mountain areas because there are very few weather stations in Mountains, he is confident about the possibility of using those available data to generate accurate prediction Model. A website has been developped for that purpose http://cip.csag.uct.ac.za.

 Contacts and prospected collaborations

It is relevant to mention that collaborations exist between colleagues of Research Institutes (SAEON, Wildlife), Universities (University of Kwazulu Natal; University of Pretoria and University of Cape Town) in South Africa. There are few mentions or reports of collaborative research with other research groups in Africa. The University of Cape Town is a member of worldwide networks involving data modelling meteorological data CODEX, EUFP7 Capacity programs such as START. A database www.cip.csag.uct.ac.za has been developed for mapping rainfall distribution in Africa. 

 Contribution to the United Nations (UNFCCC, Rio+20) and country’s concern about the issue of Global Change Research in African Mountains.

South Africa is one of the leading country in the preparation of the Rio+20 draft for Africa. People who in charge of those important world events are not necessarily scientists or researchers. Although South Africa has a good number of IPCC stakeholders and Rio+20, there is a low reflection of research product in country’s annual report and United Nation conferences. The importance of research in South African Mountains holds its substance in the water issue with the Department of Water Affairs and the fact that Mountains constitutes the major source of water for South Africa and country like Lesotho. Therefore, many researchers have stressed the gap between research output and there translation into tangible actions or decisions by policy-makers.

South Africa is equipped with substantial institutions and research centres that cover all of environmental, geological, conservation, climatology and agro forestry aspects. Although all research studies are not exclusively focussed on Mountains, one shouldd admit that the altitude component and the importance of Mountains as water catchments are entirely included in their research. There is a consistent database of more than 50 years collection in relation to meteorological parameters that is available. However, the meeting revealed the poor connection between research output and policy-making. Hence, it is an urgent need to strengthen the link between researchers and deciders.


Fundamental research questions hypothesis that can be developed further as regional research proposals. 

During our survey in South Africa, a number of research questions have arisen; Here are some fundamental research questions that may be developped as research proposal or projects:

  • How do we mitigate stream information or contradiction of meteorological data with National Policy?
  • What are the land surface responses to charge of rain intensity, soil moisture, and river flows?
  • Influence of Mountain in climate modelling
  • The role of historical data
  • Learning socio ecological system for water management and catchments taking into account water sewage to the dam in relation to population forming due to several activities (agriculture)
  • Characterization of the fynbosch in African Mountains (Mont Mlanghe in Malawi)
  • How do we control invasive plant species in water catchments and rivers?
  • Development of Model for Crops: Data collection, Challenges and Weather generator
  • Bridging Gaps between research and Policy in a changing Africa
  • Comparison Approaches climate change Research North-South
  • Land use Management in relation to water availability in Mountains area
  • Occult precipitation or Cloud and Fog precipitation studies in African Mountains
  • The Drakensberg’s vegetation is changing fast: are Brachens potential indicators of tree expansion?
  • Assessing the CO2 emission in the Drakensberg vegetation

 

Normal 0 false false false EN-ZA X-NONE X-NONE KZNWildlife
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting 2011: Part 1

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 25 January 2012
The MRI

I wished that I had a dime for every time I heard people complain about how big the AGU meeting has grown! It is an enormous meeting: the number of participants this year was rumored to be around 22,000 people. Moscone South, the venue for the poster sessions, stretches one entire city block so that if you forget something at one end and remember it only at the other end, you are in for a hike back to retrieve your stuff! And shuttling back and forth between Moscone South and Moscone West, where the sessions are held, became a bit like a salmon run with hundreds of researchers streaming from one venue to the other. It was hard to advance if you are going against the flow.

But it is the very size of the AGU that makes it such a useful meeting. While not all the world's earth science researchers attend, a significant fraction do, including very strong representations from East Asia. And the AGU meeting management provides very good tools for navigating the 12,000 posters and 6,000 invited presentations.

I found so much relevant material at the AGU meeting that I have decided to break this blog entry into two parts. This first part will explain the informational resources that I have brought back from the meeting and highlight some of the talks that caught my attention. The second will explore some of themes that I saw emerging from the conference as relevant to MRI.

 

Informational Resources

 

The AGU Scientific Program webpage appears to be public so that you can search the program and create an itinerary (complete with abstracts) as I did (see below) even if you were not registered to attend.

 

In addition, poster presenters were encouraged to submit their posters to an "ePosters" site. Thus if you know the session code for the poster (and if the presenters uploaded their poster to the site, which alas many did not), one can download the poster! For instance the very first poster in my itinerary, C11B-0674. Glacier Surge-like signals detected by SAR-based technique in West Kunlun Shan, NW Tibet T. Yasuda; M. Furuya, has been uploaded to the site. By inserting the code "C11B-0674", I can download the poster itself.

 

Finally, the AGU has finally begun to record some of the presentations and has made them available via a Sessions on Demand button.  The AGU recorded numerous Union sessions and plenary lectures over the five days of the meeting. I suggest that you look at all five days to see what might be of interest to you. I particularly suggest the sessions GC43G Stephen Schneider session and the GC43H session on the history of global warming, both on 8 December 2011.

 

What exactly did I do? I searched the program using keywords such as "mountain", "Sierra", "Himalaya", "Tibet", and so on. After several iterations, I arrived at a nearly feasible itinerary focused on mountain-related topics, which runs to 254 pages and 18.3 MB. This itinerary kept me shuttling back and forth between sessions and posters for the whole time that I was there. I was extremely pleased with this modus operandi as I felt like I was able to focus right in on the most relevant work presented at the meeting. While I was not present on Friday,  I included Friday in my itinerary document so that the full five days were searched.

 

How can you use this mountain-focused itinerary of posters and papers? If you browse the first pages of the itinerary you will find the titles of papers and posters by session. Yes, there are 27 pages to this section of the document but as the papers and posters are organized by session title, you should be able to see quickly those that are of interest to you.

To see the abstract of any of the posters or papers listed there, simply search the rest of the document for the name of the first author and you will eventually find the abstract.

Papers and posters that made an impression on me


B12B-01. Mechanisms of Alpine Treeline Stability (Invited) W.K. Smith; G. Wieser; F. Holtmeier

I am always taken by papers that explain something at one level by mechanisms at another. Bill Smith assessed treeline dynamics by looking first at seeding survival, then at growth of seedling to tree stature and finally the facilitation of survival and growth by the presence of existing vegetation. Seedling survival was a question not just of carbon acquisition under low temperatures, high radiation loads and water stress but also of the processing of that carbon into plant structures. Snow played an important role is protecting seedlings and young trees but also presented physical challenges, especially abrasion, to growth above the snow layer into tree form. Finally, the presence of other plants greatly influenced the success of plants moving from one life stage to the next, a point also made by Lara Kueppers in one of her several papers or posters on the Alpine Treeline Warming Experiment on Niwot Ridge (though I can't seem to find mention of it in the abstracts). Smith emphasized that from an ecophysiological point of view, high elevations differ considerably from low-elevation polar environments in at least two ways - very high incoming radiation which often leads to photoinhibition of carbon processing, and very low partial pressures of CO2 with large impacts of fluxes. These two points seem directly relevant to the "why are mountains different" theme that was proposed by Mark Williams and Dave Schimel in Perth last year.


C23F-03. Mountain front precipitation accumulation over a 3300m elevation gradient from scanning LiDAR snow depth and in-situ instrumental measurements, southern Sierra Nevada, California P.B. Kirchner; R.C. Bales; J. Flanagan; K.N. Musselman; N.P. Molotch

I am always on the lookout for papers that examine the relationship between elevation and precipitation. Pete Kirchner created a very high resolution dataset on spring snow depths from the difference between snow-on and snow-off LIDAR measures, and found three distinction relationships between snow depth and elevation: a steep relationship below 2100m where precipitation was frequently mixed rain and snow, a shallower but highly significant relationship above 2100m (in non-forested areas), and then a flat relationship but with great variance at high elevation where snow redistribution was dominant.

Related talks included Danny Marks who reported on trends and projections of the rain-snow transition line and its impacts on runoff, a poster by Anders looking at elevation- precipitation relationships from different mountain regions around the world, and another poster by Minders looking at the mechanisms for ascent-forced convective precipitation over a mountainous island in the Caribbean. Minder also gave a good paper on the mechanisms for a lowering of snow line as the rain-snow transition zone approached mountain fronts.

 

A23E-06. Representation of the Sierra Barrier Jet in 11 years of a high-resolution dynamical reanalysis downscaling M.R. Hughes; P.J. Neiman; E. Sukovich; F.M. Ralph

Just prior to Minder's paper on declining snow line, I listened to a fascinating talk about a low level jet that runs parallel to the Sierra Nevada in California. For years I lived in the foothills of the Sierra, and never did I suspect that a thousand feet above me was a river of air moving parallel to the crest that forced upward incoming Pacific moisture and thus initiated precipitation well before the mountains. Several other talks in this session examined the nature and the impacts of the jet. I wondered if such jets were features in other mountain ranges as well, such as the Himalaya, that block prevailing winds.

 

H24D-05. Widespread hillslope gullying on the southeastern Tibetan Plateau: Human or climate-change induced? (Invited) J.D. Pelletier; J. Quade; R. Goble; M. Aldenderfer

Having seen these gullies myself, I had to go to this talk, which concluded quite simply that the advent of pastoralism with a reduction in vegetation cover was insufficient in itself to initiate gullying, as gullying had not begun in earlier, drier periods when the vegetation cover had been previously reduced. The gullying required as well on-going and increasing precipitation of the late Holocene to push the landscape over a threshold. I like this line of inquiry as I think climate change impacts on geomorphology in mountains is not well researched.

 

GC32B-03. The Modification of Orographic Snow Growth Processes by Cloud Nucleating Aerosols (Invited) W.R. Cotton; S. Saleeby

I listened to Bill Cotton four years ago at a meeting that MRI recorded in Boulder CO . I found his talk quite interesting then and so I expected a good talk this time. I was not disappointed. Here he talked about how aerosols, which can come from pollution, changed the rate at which snow flakes form and fall, so much so that horizontal winds push the precipitation further downwind often for 10's of kilometers. In the area of the study (on the Continental Divide in Colorado) this horizontal shift in precipitation moved significant amounts of precipitation from the Colorado River Basin on the Pacific side of the Divide to the North Platte River on the Atlantic side. Thus aerosol pollution can change not only the amount but also the location of precipitation.

 

GC32B-04. Hydrometeorological Scales Interactions in the Andes and their Impact on the Amazon Climate (Invited) R. Avissar; D. Medvigy; R.L. Walko

This talk showed the importance of mountains to the climate of surrounding areas. These researchers use the Ocean-Land-Atmosphere Model, which, besides featuring these coupled elements, models the entire planet using a variable sized grid. It thus produces regional climate predictions from a single model with a very fine grid spacing in regions of interest and larger grid spacing over the rest of the globe. Here they demonstrated that if one did not model the topography of the Andes at a sufficiently fine scale, then predictions of the inter-annual variability of precipitation over the Amazon were incorrect. I would have liked to have heard exactly what about the topography was important in getting better predictions of precipitation over the Amazon, but a little more digging in ISI will probably lead me to the answer.

 

C33F-08. Past peak water in Peru’s Cordillera Blanca: diagnosing the demise of glacier influence on stream discharge M. Baraer; B.G. Mark; J.M. McKenzie

Michel Baraer participated as well in the MRI KCW on 4 Dec in Berkeley. His talk here reviewed the expected time course for stream discharge from basins in which glaciers are receding, that is, an initial increase in discharge due to the melting ice volume and then when the glaciers are considerably small a reduction in discharge. He then reviewed discharge data to show that "peak water" had already occurred in the Cordillera Blanca of Peru, and that stream discharge was now on the descending limb of the expected curve. Thus the Cordillera Blanca is now where other major "glacierized" basins, such as those in the Alps, Central Asia and the Himalayas, may be in the future.

 

GC34A-08. Non-linear feedbacks between climate change, hydrologic partitioning, plant available water, and carbon cycling in montane forests (Invited) P.D. Brooks; M.E. Litvak; A.A. Harpold; N.P. Molotch; J.C. McIntosh; P.A. Troch; X. Zapata

Paul Brook's talk was one of eight talks in the CIRMOUNT-organized session: GC34A. Climate Change and Drought: Climatic Water Deficit and Water Balance in Mountain Systems: Biophysics, Ecohydrology, and Impacts.  All the talks here revolved around the ecological importance of potential evapotranspiration, actual evapotranspiration, and the difference between the two, climatic water deficit. All of these measures integrate precipitation and energy over the annual cycle and so are more pertinent than total annual precip or mean annual temperature at explaining the distribution and abundance of organism. I recommend that you look at all the abstracts in this session.

Brook's talk focused on some of the mechanisms related to snow accumulation and melt that strongly influenced water availability to vegetation. These include sublimation of snow, which is strongly influenced by tree canopy cover, and the depth of early snow pack as it influences the depth of frost in the soil and the soil's subsequent porosity at the time of spring snow melt. Once again, factors that one might not suspect at first (e.g. the degree of tree canopy or the timing and depth of first snowfall) turn out to be very important in the ecohydrology of mountains. Only when we know these will we be able to project better the impact of future climate and land cover change.

 

C44A-04. Past and future glacier changes the western Nyainqentanglha Range on the Tibetan Plateau (Invited) T. Bolch; F. Chen; W. Yang; M. Buchroithner; E. Huintjes; S. Kang; A. Linsbauer; F. Maussion; F. Paul; C. Schneider; D. Scherer; T. Yao

Tobias Bolch of the University of Zürich gave several talks at the AGU, all of them excellent. One (C43A-02) focused on a summary of glacier trends over the entire Himalaya, a definitive statement of which is essential in the face of the erroneous statements in the IPCC AR4. This talk (C44A-04) highlighted a method to assess glacial area and volume over time that is applicable at the scale of an entire mountain range. The relevance and clarity of the question was matched by the scope and completeness of the answer, representing to me the best of what research can do.

 

GC13C-06. Hurricanes in a Warming Climate (Invited) K. Emanuel

One of the reasons to go to the AGU is to hear talks from people who have made important contributions to the climate change debate (or to other scientific questions, such as the origin of life), even if their contribution has nothing to do with mountains. Kerry Emanuel updated his findings on the growing intensity of Atlantic hurricanes. He presented an amazing map of historic tropical cyclone paths, which clearly showed that the Pacific Ocean has many more tropical cyclones than the Atlantic ( a similar image is here) and leads one to wonder why the media focuses so strongly on Atlantic hurricanes.  He noted that there is no climate change signal apparent in the intensity of Pacific cyclones, which seems to vary with ENSO. However the intensity of Atlantic hurricanes does show a climate change signal, a combination of warming sea surface temperatures coupled with a cooling tropical tropopause. He emphasized that the damage from cyclones is overwhelming associated with a few high-intensity storms so even a minor increase in intensity would have major impacts on damage.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Swiss-Austrian Alliance for Mountain Research

by Astrid
Astrid
Environmental Scientist, Development Specialist, Writer and Illustrator.
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 17 January 2012
MRI Europe

Swiss-Austrian Memorandum signed

End of October 2011, on occasion of the visit of the Austrian Minister of Research Karlheinz Töchterle to Switzerland, a Memorandum of Understanding targeting at a ‘Swiss-Austrian Alliance for the promotion of basic and applied research to support sustainable development in the mountain regions of Europe’ has been signed. With this Memorandum the Swiss State Secretariat for Education at the Swiss Federal Department of Home Affairs of the Swiss Confederation and the Austrian Federal Ministry for Science and Research declared their interest to strengthen and expand the bilateral activities in the field of science and research in mountain regions. This includes the further development of European research activities contributing to sustainable mountain development, the promotion of science networks and the development of co-operations between research and practice. In short, the Memorandum articulates the desire to continue activities that were launched under the MRI-Europe Program for the period 2012-2016.

Future Opportunities

The Memorandum is a milestone. A milestone proving the fact that every crisis bears a chance or that every cloud has a silver lining. Since the establishment of the MRI-Europe Program in 2007, the quickly evolving network faced financial crises on an annual basis. Yet, always with a happy ending. In 2008, the lacking resources paved the way to the collaboration with the Institute for Mountain Research (IGF) of the Austrian Academy of Sciences. Despite the still existing funding constraints, or maybe because of them, new networks emerged in the Carpathians (2008) and Southeastern Europe (2009) with an extraordinary high commitment from the region. In 2010, the terminated funding from the Swiss National Science Foundation jeopardized the continuation of the MRI-Europe Program, which in turn mobilized funds from the Swiss State Secretariat for Education and Research to run the Program for a limited period. This again triggered discussions on capitalizing on the recent achievements in mountain research and networking over the long term, which resulted in the undersigning of the above Memorandum.


Is this the end of a sequence of crisis?

That remains to be proved. Despite the commitment to support scientific networking and mountain research at the European scale, the current financial administration makes it impossible to continue the payment of the MRI-Europe Program manager’s salary on a joint basis. With the consequence that the mountain research vision has been unified while the mountain research program is cut in two: with a part time manager in Berne and a part time manager in Innsbruck.
If the new Swiss-Austrian Alliance really and truly wants to succeed in pooling forces and resources towards more coordinated mountain research in Europe, the current setting issues a challenge to the MRI and IGF. I am curious to see the next silver lining appear behind the clouds.

0 votes

Urbanization Workshop in Nainital India

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 01 December 2011
The MRI
Despite some unfortunate last minute cancellations due to family affairs and illness the MRI Synthesis Workshop on Urbanization in High Mountain Regions (1-5 November) was a great success. Prakash Tiwari and his wife, Bhagwati Joshi, did an excellent job as local hosts, setting us up in the best hotel in Nainital, the Manu Maharani, a decision not without some poignancy as such luxury hotels are a key element in the development of some mountain cities and are not without their share of controversies.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Science in mountains yields dramatic, important work from dramatic, important sites

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 09 September 2011
The MRI
As I was not able to participate in the Sonnblick Conference I asked Chris Ritter, MRI's Communications and Events Manager, to write up his impressions of the meeting:
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Integrated Global Observing Systems

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 09 September 2011
The MRI
The group brought together in Oxford by IGBP AIMES (Analysis, Integration and Modeling of the Earth System) and the European Space Agency clearly agreed that some mountains regions, particularly in Asia and Africa, were, among other kinds of places, poorly observed.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Third Pole in Iceland

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 06 September 2011
The MRI
The reason that I was not in Salzburg at the 125th Sonnblick Anniversary meeting on Climate Change in High Mountain Regions, a conference of which MRI was a co-sponsor, was the third Third Pole Environment (TPE) workshop in Iceland.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Carpe Diem

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 01 September 2011
The MRI
The activities that really get traction are almost never the activities that you plan for, but rather are those that you think up on the fly. I noticed this years ago when back in California, I worked at a very innovative program called the California Forest and Rangeland Resource Assessment Program. It was, as with many things Californian, way ahead of its time, staffed with bright people and equipped with state-of-the-art GIS technology.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

looks like a busy fall

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 27 July 2011
The MRI

Session titles are now available for the IGBP Congress in March 2012 with abstracts due on 19 August 2011.

It's worth a few minutes of your time to peruse the list of sessions. There should shortly be a session on mountains in that list, but there are already some quite interesting sessions. One that caught my eye was one on tipping points in social networks chaired by Andy Revkin and involving Google and BBC.  Such a session smacks of the real world of politics and perception, a topic that, while recognized as central to our issue, never seems to be explored well enough at these kinds of meetings.

 

1 vote

Looks like a busy fall

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Monday, 11 July 2011
The MRI

Session titles are now available for the IGBP Congress in March 2012 with abstracts due on 19 August 2011.

It's worth a few minutes of your time to peruse the list of sessions. There should shortly be a session on mountains in that list, but there are already some quite interesting sessions.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Back in Switzerland for the summer

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Monday, 27 June 2011
The MRI
Back in Switzerland, I continued to work on the TPE Science Plan, implementing my suggestions for the Plan myself. I had warned my Chinese colleagues while in Beijing that had I made all my proposed changes in the Plan itself without first taking them through my guide to changes, it would look as if I were completely rewriting the Plan.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Back in Beijing

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 01 June 2011
The MRI
From 22 May to 2 June I was once again back in Beijing on my Chinese Academy of Sciences Visiting Professorship with the Institute of Tibetan Plateau Research, working Prof, Yao Tandong on the Science Plan for the Third Pole Environment project.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Workshops Taking Shape

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 20 May 2011
The MRI
The biggest news for me personally is that I will be returning to China on Sunday 22 May 2011 as part of my on-going CAS Visiting Professorship. Unlike last year's trips, this one is lightning quick - just 10 days - to work with Prof. Yao and the ITP staff on the Science Plan for the Third Pole Environment Project. I'll be back on 2 June, but not back in the office until the following Tuesday, 7 June 2011. Yao tells me the weather in Beijing is nice right now.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Personal impressions from the AAG meeting

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 29 April 2011
The MRI
I asked members of the MRI community who attended the AAG meeting to send me their thoughts about the meeting.  Here are some edited notes.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

12th Swiss Global Change Day

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 21 April 2011
The MRI

On Tuesday, 19 April 2011, most of the MRI office staff participated in the 12th Swiss Global Change Day,  an event sponsored by ProClim, the Swiss Academy of Science's platform for climate change. This event brings together in Bern nearly all the Swiss researchers working on global change and so is the premiere networking event for our community in Switzerland. It is definitely a "be-there-or-be-square" event!

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Activity on many fronts

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 06 April 2011
The MRI
It is getting crowded at the MRI office.! We have five people on salary, all but me part-time but just three workstations in the office. According to the most recent update of our "staff location" spreadsheet all three stations are full occupied four days of the week, with me working in Lausanne on Tuesday and Thursday.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

World Mountain Forum

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Saturday, 19 March 2011
The MRI
We are making progress on establishing more MRI regional coordinators. As a result of discussions ancillary to our recent Rio+20 meeting in Rome, we have lined up funding at the FAO for an MRI Africa coordinator through November 2013, and at CONDESAN for an MRI Latin America coordinator through December 2013.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Report from the Inception Meeting at the FAO for Rio+20

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Monday, 28 February 2011
The MRI
From Sunday 20.02.2011 to Wednesday 23.02.2011, I participated in a Mountain Partnership Consortium meeting at the FAO in Rome to launch the MPC's SDC-financed preparation for the 2012 Earth Summit, aka Rio+20.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Progess of the Synthesis Workshops and News Feed

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 17 February 2011
The MRI

We are making good progress of several of the Synthesis Workshops.

On 7 February 2011 MRI hosted a conference call with Julia Klein, Jill Baron,  Anne Nolin and me to discuss the coupled human-earth system theme. The
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Good news!

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 10 February 2011
The MRI
The State Secretary for Education and Research has agreed to fund MRI-Europe for 2011 and will engage in discussions with their homologues in Austria to determine an equitable arrangement for 2012. This means that MRI-Europe, which was cut out of the MRI SNF grant, now sufficient funds for this year. Soon Astrid Björnsen and I can begin implementing the MRI-Europe priorities.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

What did I learn in Chambéry?

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 04 February 2011
The MRI
I spent a day and a half at a CIRCLE2 (Climate Impact Research and Response Coordination for a Larger Europe) meeting in Chambéry, and what did I get out of it?
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Perth Strategy Progress Report

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 19 January 2011
The MRI

It's now almost four months since the MRI Strategy Session at Perth, Scotland, and time to take a first look at progress toward the activities discussed there.

Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Personnel changes and news feeds

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Sunday, 02 January 2011
The MRI
Chris Ritter takes over from Sandra Liechti as MRI's Scientific Communications and Event Manager. Sandra did a great job for us for a bit more than a year and is now moving on to new challenges.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Mountain topics at the AGU

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Saturday, 18 December 2010
The MRI
Let me stress again that readers who want to learn more about talks and posters given by authors in bold text can access the abstracts by downloading the pdf of my itinerary and searching the document for the author's last name.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

First days at AGU

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 16 December 2010
The MRI
The first talk that I heard at the AGU Meeting was given by Dave Schimel, the head of NEON, and focused on climate controls on the carbon cycle. (You can find abstracts of the presentations by authors shown in bold by searching within the pdf of my itinerary at the AGU).
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

AGU 2010 - Key Contacts Workshop

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 14 December 2010
The MRI
"Great format!", " A lot of fun!", "Great site and super food!"  Once MRI received accolades for its Key Contacts Workshop at the UCB Faculty Club on the Sunday before the start of the AGU.  Note: Look at the album "AGU 2010" for photos from the workshop and other photos taken at the AGU meeting itself. Part
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Lanzhou and Xining

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Friday, 10 December 2010
The MRI
From Nov 29 to Dec 3 I went back out to western China (photos are in an album called Lanzhou and Xining), which is really central China geographically, but certainly west of the cultural center of gravity of the country. I went first to Lanzhou, the capital of Gansu Province, and then Xining, the capital of Qinghai Province. These
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Don't neglect the albums!

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 01 December 2010
The MRI
I have been taking photos of nearly everyone I meet at the various Universities and Institutes where I give my "interdisciplinary earth system science" presentation. It is a way of connecting well the names and faces of people, which, given the nearly Teflon-like character of Chinese names in the context of my gray matter, might easily float apart in my brain.  This
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

The mountains of western Sichuan

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Sunday, 21 November 2010
The MRI
Why did I go to Chengdu? First of all, I wanted to make connections at the CAS Institute of Mountain Hazards and Environment. The Institute has five divisions: mountain hazards, mountain environmental change, mountain development, GIS and remote sensing applications and a special unit examining hazards in Sichuan Province.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Around the world to TPE Workshop in Kathmandu

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Wednesday, 10 November 2010
The MRI
It was an amazing trip from the GLP meeting in Tempe, Arizona to the second Third Pole Environment (TPE) Workshop in Kathmandu, Nepal. I had intended to return to Beijing for a few days and then continue on to Kathmandu, but an insufficient number of entries into China on my visa made that option impossible. And
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Thursday, 21 October 2010

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Thursday, 21 October 2010
The MRI
Afternoon of the first day and all of the second day of the GLP Conference The first two afternoon plenaries, though given by relatively big names, were not noteworthy but the final plenary by Diane Liverman was meaty.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

Tuesday, 19 October 2010

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Tuesday, 19 October 2010
The MRI
The first of the three days of the GLP conference at Arizona State University was a joint GLP- UGEC (Urbanization and Global Environmental Change) session. The main storyline of the first plenaries was:
Tags: Untagged
0 votes

First week in Beijing 10-15 October 2010

by Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood
Gregory Greenwood director of MRI. http://194.150.248.152/~swissmat/index.php?o
User is currently offline
on Saturday, 16 October 2010
The MRI
Dr. Yao, the Director of the Institute of Tibetan Plateau Research (ITP) confirmed his agreement with the interdisciplinary focus of my Visiting Professorship. My proposal was very clear in this regard but I felt that it was necessary to get his verbal confirmation. His commitment to my participation was confirmed in another way by his insistence that I participate in the second TPE workshop to be held in Kathmandu from 26 to 28 October.
Tags: Untagged
0 votes